The yarn changes colors in magical ways, and the two balls were not identical, but marry very nicely, and I love them. I am not hung up on having matchy-matchy socks. This yarn makes it impossible to know how they will turn out until you are done. That is the nature of the yarn, and I love that. My self-striping socks do just that, self-stripe. I love that, and I don't care if the stripes line up exactly, fraternal socks are just fine by me. They are still beautiful, and created by my own hands. That being said, this is the comment that I got from the State Fair judge:
Click on it, blow it up, it says "Would have been first but not a pair...
I did have one person ask if I left the second sock at home, but I did not! I take no offense what so ever to the people who did place and get ribbons. From the pictures I have seen (Football season - did not make it there in person) there was a lot of lovely work. I am glad to see that so many people entered. That is what makes the state fair wonderful. That said, quilters have no business judging knitting. The socks turned out the way that they did, because that is the nature of the yarn. They most definitely are a PAIR. And then to tell me that I would have gotten first, but instead did not even get a participation ribbon (not sure if they did that this year or not) is nothing short of frustrating.
I worked hard on my socks, and I am very proud of them. In fact, I am going to work on writing up the pattern after having so many ask about it. It may end up being a sock of the month at Twist at some point in time, but I am going to write up the pattern (not sure how to fit it all into my schedule - that is why I am starting now). This judge will certainly not deter me, or change how I want to make my socks, but it just stands to show, quilters are perfect to judge quilters, but only knitters should be allowed to judge other knitting work.
It is one of the reasons that I am working on this pattern, because other knitters like it, and have asked for it. Okay, I will get off my soap box now.
3 comments:
I LOVE the socks, and I agree when you have people who have no idea what they are judging it is impossible to get a fair representation. I am glad you are not going to let "those stinkin' judges" (angry pirate voice) rain on your parade. They are Best in Show to me.
Deb
I noticed some freaky judging in Domestic Arts, just in the few cards I looked at (I didn't enter anything this year, myself, though usually I'm off in Fine Arts anyway).
For instance, the pop-tab purse with the snarky "these are not beads!" comment. Granted, I'm not a fiber artist, but it seems to me that the principle is the same: they're hard objects with holes in them, you crochet or knot or knit or whatever around them just the same. The twenty-five-words-or-less description for each category isn't exactly a fount of guidance as to what's kosher, so you'd think they could go for less snark and more slack.
It kind of made me wonder... are the judges getting old and cranky and need to retire? Or did the judges retire, and this is the new generation trying to make a statement?
I love your socks. They're all gorgeous (even if they're not a pair). I'm in shock that someone would make a comment like that. It's so completely obvious that they go together!
See ya around Twist!
Post a Comment